of course, the stains!! good idea

how about any of the following:
- caramel (one of my favourite mlbb colours)
- rhapsody (warmer than aria)
- skinny dip (less brown than jaybird)
- st. tropez (love this one as a pinky nude too)

too overwhelmed to order it all looks so great!!
and congrats on your 6th anniversary

Birthday Suit and Jaybird are very different on, especially for someone who likes brown tones. One looks plummy/mauve/brown, the other reddish/brown. JenW, that's exactly what i was thinking, too. birthday suit could turn out very plummy on "too purple" lips. roxie underneath could counte...

i can really recommend:

- bon bon as a very wearable sheer brown
- caramel, a slightly peachy brown nude
- skinny dip is a pretty, shimmery brown with a touch of pink

if your sister finds her lips "too purple", roxie might be a good neutralizer under any other colour lipstick as well

thanks for the info, catlover

there i go, down on my knees, begging for moisture magic to make a comeback!! thanks

honeysuckle has been discontinued, sadly before i could buy it :( regarding the shimmer in the buttercreams i have: - heirloom: out of the 4 i have this is the most shimmery, not junky glitter though! the shimmer forms a very solid pink with subtle silver glints on my lips - very wearable!! - dame: ...

oooh, i so so want a cream bronzer (and more subtle cream highligher) too! cream bronzer would be great all year round, especially as a contour. it can be applied with precision on the target areas, and they do blend so well!! i asked for it last spring, and again this autumn. maybe we have more luc...

have you tried - tarnish = shimmery silver - amethyst = purple - envy = green? oh, and if you don't own the cream eyeliner palette, it's really good to try out all the colours in one handy little place ;) sadly, black cherry was discontinued before i could try it, but it must have been legendary for...

i googled for images, but i don't think SN has an exact dupe for this gloss. although i find that most of the lip swatches look like a clear gloss, judging from the colour description (nude caramel brown color with some peachy pink) i would suggest to try either caramel or mirage topped with a clear...