Script isn't as reddish and I think is more matte.

I'd also like something in more of a warm red or orangey-red brown:)

Hi,

For those of us who like sharp lines but aren't adept with brushes, it would be great to have an eyeliner pen. That is my last product for which I haven't found a health dupe.

Yeah!

You listened -- and my brown mascara is on it's way!!

If it's as good as the black, I'll even be able to resist using my Diorshow:) And I promise to keep posting reviews of it wherever I can. (Reviewed the black on Makeupalley already.)

Any chance of a purply or blue?

Me, too, for the brown mascara! I figured out how to register and log in just to ask for this. (Thought that registering at Silk naturals meant registering at the forum, so it took a while to figure out there was no problem with password, etc.) Anyway, I LOVE the mascara except for the color. Gave i...