Wow neither did mine, after I went to the Paypal page it showed it had taken off my points, but not my GC... now I'm paying $50 more than I expected per order.

Ok one worked on my second order... weiiiiiird. Here's what I ended up getting:
Order 1
1 x Sample Raspberry Moisturizer
1 x 2% BHA Toner
1 x Hemp Moisturizer
1 x Carrot & Pumpkin Salve
1 x Citrus Toner Concentrate
1 x Floral toner concentrate
1 x After Bath Lotion Bar
1 x Apricot Cleansing Oil (SIL)
1 x Intensive Moisturizer w/CoQ10 and Reonvage (SIL)
1 x Facelift Vitamin C, DMAE & Peptide serum (SIL)
1 x Holy Crow! Instant Wrinkle Remover (SIL)
1 x Daily Defense Moisturizer (BF)
2 x Sifters for Sample Jars- 5 pack
1 x Empty 50 ml Foaming Bottle
1 x Date Bait- Bronze Tinted Perfecting Powder
1 x Sample Sleep in a Jar- Light Peach
1 x Sample Sleep in a Jar- Medium
1 x Refill Heavy Coverage Ivory
1 x Refill Medium Coverage Ivory
1 x Super Soft Vegan Synthetic Kabuki Brush
1 x Long Handled Baby Kabuki Brush- Great for Foundation and Blush
1 x Fiber Optic Blush Brush
1 x Sample Stardust - MAC Moon River clone
1 x Sample Carnal Blush
1 x Sample Babydoll Blush
1 x Sample Lovelace Blush
1 x Sample Cosmic- cool pink shimmer blush- MAC Love Rock Clone
Bewitched, Brimstone, Eerie, Fete, and Fire as GWP requests
Order 2
1 x Lake- grey/blue satin shimmer
1 x Plush- Purple and Copper Shimmer Eye Shadow
1 x Slick- metallic brownish silver- BE 1980's clone
1 x Smokey Plum Quad
1 x Twilight Deep Smokey Blue Satin
1 x Vogue- very deep shimmery golden copper brown
1 x Mixed Metal Palette
And Luxe and Legend as my GWP requests.