Silk Naturals

I wanted to get a pinkish lip gloss for my MIL and was wondering about the difference (color) between these two..is there any other pink lip gloss with no carmine or FD&C? TIA

Also, does darling have carmines/FD&C?

Can't help with ingredient info, but there's a good selection of swatches including Soft in Jen's colour swatch thread, pinned to the top of the forum. There's a swatch of Aria on the product page, so that'll give a good comparison if you compare those two.

Darling, Aria, Sweetheart, and Jaybird just have iron oxides- the rest have a smidge of FD&C color or occasionally carmine.

Thank you, Helena and Karen!
I am getting Aria for my MIL as she wanted a moisturizing lippie and loved the sound of the ingredients in the black label lippies..

For my own reference, here are some more comparison swatches:

Aria on left, Soft on right