Thank you for your reply! I see that I left out a lot of info, it would probably be helpful if I wrote a little more detailed.
I've used both the KISS cleanser and the apricot oil one, I have sometimes wondered if the KISS cleanser maybe dried out my skin but I didn't see any improvements when using the apricot cleanser so I ruled those out.
I was using the oatmeal serum and the hemp moisturizer for maybe a year but I switched to green tea & aloe to see if there would be any improvement (there wasn't). I don't remember if it was after or around the same time that I started using Awesome Sauce too. No problems there either but still oily.
When I ran out of the hemp moisturizer I just went without a moisturizer for a while but my skin started getting very dry and I got problems with flaky skin so I started ordering samples to see if there was a moisturizer that could help with the oil problem but no dice. Instead I started getting pimples.
I do blot although wiping seems to work better. As soon as I get to work (that's about 1 hour after my morning routines) I go to the bathroom to blot and then every hour or every other hour... My skin isn't that sensitive so I usually experiment with whatever comes to mind, but not taking it slow makes it harder to eliminate what does what of course.
I wonder if maybe I don't use enough of the products or that I use too much - 1-2 drops of serum is enough to cover my face but it doesn't leave it damp for longer than 20-30 seconds. How much are you supposed to use?
I would like to get the oiliness under control with just skincare, if possible. I can't use the zink powder, perfecting powder or even foundation without my skin starting to produce even more oil so it's definitely lacking something...but what? I'll keep your suggestions in mind though, thanks for the tips!