I agree with ErinL's request for a lippie that is peachy-pink with gold shimmer. For me, it doesn't have to be a wand gloss, any lippie is awesome! But I am OBSESSED with peachy-pinky-gold makeup. I have MAC Nymphette Lipglass, MAC Sandy B lipstick, and the only thing stopping me from NARS Orgasm was the yucky plastic taste. But SN lippies are the absolute best. Like Precious (my very first SN lippie ever!), but more pigmented. More pink, more peachy, and more noticeable gold shimmer (not TOO sparkly though...probably). A more pigmented Nymphette/Orgasm dupe.
Other than that, I agree with everyone else! Xarata read my mind when she asked for the lip exfoliator stick (I have a hard time with the looser grains of sugar - they go everywhere on my face but my lips).
Also, Cupcake completely and totally read my mind (we must somehow all be on the same brainwave!) when she asked for a lip balm formula in a "pod." I was so going to ask for it! I love the lip balm formula (I am picky about my lip balms!) but I also love any kind of salve or balm type of formula for everything, particularly multi-purpose. And I am strange and like cute little pots/tins/jars...I know people always say they're unhygienic but I always have hand sanitizer and I like to really glob on my lip balm. So to summarize, I agree with Cupcake and would love a sort of thinner, smooshier version of the lip balms in a non-twist-stick package.
One veeery last thing - I have been on the hunt lately for a bluey-grey eyeshadow. Preferably matte, and much more on the grey side than the blue so as to completely avoid any potential 80s looks. Sort of a steel or storm blue (those colors in my imagination), like a darker Dove crossed with, say, Twilight. But matte. Rather like "Cool Gray"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cool_gray#Cool_gray or "Slate Gray."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slate_gray